I don’t know about the efficiency, but you should probably step up the cct on the dedomed 519 if you want to end up at 2700. They warm up when you dedome them.
Your cct is the color temperature, in this case you’re looking for 2700K.
When you dedome a 519A, the color temperature of the LED gets warmer than it was originally. That means that for the dedome option, if you want to land at 2700 you probably need the original LED to be aroung 3500K.
Not a clue about D4s, but decide first if you like hotspot+spill from a reflector, or mostly hospot from a TIR lens. If it’s got a reflector, maybe a 17mm TIR lens would be better, or v/v if you like the opposite.
Dedoming loses you some lemons, even though you get more throw.
So basically, it’s just a balancing act of a few different factors.
I’d deal with 'range anxiety" by just carrying a spare cell, and just pick the beam I like best.