How to test different AA batteries using MAHA C9000?

I want to run a few tests on some various batteries including rechargeable and non rechargeable batteries using my MAHA C9000.

What things should I test and how should I test them?

For example say I want to compare 2 alkaline batteries, do I just put them in and discharge at 500-1000mA and see the results at the end?

The batteries I will be testing are:

Energizer Advance Lithium

Energizer Ultimate Lithium

Sanyo eneloop (2nd gen)

Panasonic Evolta (2nd gen)

Panasonic Evolta (3rd gen)

DSE alkaline

Varta alkaline

Ill be doing it just to satisfy my personal curiosity but I will also post my results on BLF.

Thanks for any tips.

Discharge, charge then discharge

I know I cant charge alkalines, just discharge for them?

Maybe take voltage readings as well?

it doesnt make too much sense to test alkalines since they cant provide constant current which the C9000 tries to draw. after 1 "discharge" cycle of an alkaline, the alkaline recovers (within hours or 1 day) and you could draw again energy (mAh) out of it. that's why on CPF some testers post "extended runtime tests" instead of "runtime tests". it is silly trying to measure the capacity of Alkaline cells, it doesnt make sense. try for example 1000mA current draw. the cell can provide 1.0A, constant, for maybe 5-10mins, then the current drops no matter how small the resistance of your LED is, and eventually (e.g. in brightness tests) you would have to interrupt the test .. and the Alkaline is yet half full! And extracting the other half of energy (mAh) is impossible: you wont get the 1.0A anymore.

You could try to discharge at 50mA :)

Ah I see, Im not sure I can dischage at 50mA though with the C9000 (I dont have it out at the moment)

Would the Energizer lithium batteries handle it ok or would it suffer the same as the alkaline batteries?

Maybe Ill have to think of another way to test them but runtime tests are a pain if I have to monitor them, or I might just stick to rechargeable batteries.

i cant afford Energizer Lithium, they are more expensive than Eneloops :stuck_out_tongue: so i wouldnt know.

btw, even very low currents cant be sustained by Alkalines, see the runtime graphs for Preon P0 (several reviews and tests on cpf) and also this simple graph for the Fenix E01:

if you're interested in testing cells.. i would just measure runtimes of a reference flashlight ;)

Energizer Lithium’s are just fine with continuous high-current draw.

For example, Ultimate Lithium AA's do 3033mAh at 0.3A draw, and 2984mAh (98%) at 0.8A draw - while Duracell Turbo (alkaline) do 1610mAh at 0.3A, but just 1045mAh (65%) at 0.8A.

I just got 20 OEM Energizer Ultimate Lithium AA's in the mail today, aside from the wrapper they look identical to the real ones I have in a packet.

I think Ill run a discharge test on 2 of them.

I wonder if you could safely recharge alkalines on a very low charge setting. There was a "green" charger out a few years ago that could do it.