Not enough lumens.
I wish my favourite flashlight had more lumens, its about 200 lumen max and i would love to see an updated version with at least 1000 lumen output.
Would this be my primary flashlight in a power outage? No. In fact, I don’t even own one. I admire the unusual/creative design, though. I never would’ve come up with it.
At night during a power outage, when it’s completely dark and your eyes adjust, you don’t need anything close to 200 lumens to walk about and see where you’re going…20 would more than suffice. Our AA mini-maglites in the 1980s were only about 20 lumens with a fresh set of batteries, and got dimmer from there. So, for grandma or whoever else just needs something simple and idiot-proof, this isn’t a terrible thing to have in your kitchen drawer.
I can see this being very appealing to people who are trying to save size and weight while backpacking/camping as well.
I agree that you don’t need many lumens, my 10iosh lumen ultra low on my Moon RC2 will light up a room which i have done more than once.
But that 9V won’t last that long and will give up only a couple lumens at best.
And its not rechargeable which makes it cost more than one 18650 to get the same power even once.
Yes, but like the 4-pack of terrible lights in the first post, this product isn’t for flashlight enthusiasts. It’s for the general public. They have no idea what an 18650 is, they don’t own a battery charger, and have no interest in owning a conventional flashlight because “I’ll just use my phone’s flashlight.” For that kind of person, this stupidly simple device fits the bill for an emergency/power outage backup light (or as a hiking/camping light.) There are also a lot of elderly people without cell phones who are uncomfortable with modern technology in general who need something incredibly simple.
I made plenty of S2+es and C8s that way. 1-mode driver with just 7135s and not even a µC on-board. On/off. I could’ve potted the things and made ’em nigh indestructible.
It actually sounds like we’re more alike than different to me. I don’t personally like or use AAA or 9V either. I’m strictly 14500, 18650, and 21700 these days. Having a difference of opinion doesn’t always mean someone is irritable, and if someone can use information and examples to better explain their viewpoint rather than getting upset, I’m all for it. Discussion is why forums exist. It’s not a hive mind where everyone has to agree on every topic.
I believe that if you ask 100 random people on the street what an 18650 is, 98 of them will stare blankly at you, because they have no idea what that is. 18650 isn’t on the battery rack at Wal-mart or the supermarket. This forum is a niche group of people, and a lot of products aren’t made with our standards in mind, but I acknowledge they can still be useful to people that aren’t knowledgeable on the topic of flashlights. It’s all about matching a product to the use case that fits, in my opinion. The AAA and 9V lights clearly aren’t for us, but they must meet some people’s needs, or they wouldn’t keep making them.