Patents, trolling, knockoffs, prior art, and improving the world -- thinking ahead

One useful thing groups of people can do is keep track of what’s callled “prior art” — evidence that an idea someone decided to patent is actually not a new idea.

The whole patent and “intellectual property” system is a big bucket of worms — flesh eating worms, mind you — and anyone who tries to start a small business with a new idea is apt to find that some idea has been patented, often quietly, and the patent held by “patent troll” operations that wait until someone builds up a business then leaps in to assert they have a patent and are owed money.

Old timers will recall Arc Flashlight’s story, which has apparently been airbrushed away from where I read it on a formerly valuable flashlight website — the only fragment I now find is this one where someone commented

The history is out there somewhere, but it really doesn’t matter in particular.

More to the point — staying aware of good ideas that people bring up in public and share can be helpful.

Check out how the software folks have kept ideas available when someone tried to lock them up with patents and charge whoever used them — long after the ideas were thought up and put into use.
http://www.google.com/search?q=patent+troll+“prior+art”


While I know topics like this can get contentious, I hope this doesn’t. Point is — good ideas disappear from the web sometimes. You can hope to find them at the Internet Archive.

This is what made me start thinking about this stuff. There’s going to be more and more effort made to reduce knockoffs/counterfeiting.
http://hosted.ap.org/dynamic/stories/A/AS_CHINA_COUNTERFEITING\_?SITE=AP&SECTION=HOME&TEMPLATE=DEFAULT&CTIME=2015-05-07-21-19-07

(don’t know how long that link will last, but the general story is going to be around for years).

Note, right now it’s about China. But in the 1700s and 1800s the USA was cheerfully pirating everything from Europe, what comes around goes around.

One thing I see happening with flashlights — that could be, maybe is also happening with other things people want: groups acting to come up with good new ideas and share them with people in China who can produce them inexpensively enough that everyone benefits.

This isn’t always easy — business people in China are as clueless as business people anywhere. Look at the ZeusRay story — one guy who barely understands flashlights at all listens to one guy on a blog somewhere (here) and improves a clunky product (look up “soild pillow hole”)
https://www.google.com/search?q=“soild+pillow+hole”
(add “ZeusRay” to that for the first round, but other flashlights are now using that description!)

Look at any of several group buy threads here where — with much effort, much mis-translation and sneaky substitution at the manufacturing end, much failure of understanding — people on the blog here managed to get improvements made that benefit everyone.

If you get enough smart people involved in mutual aid, better products are easier to invent — and instead of copying crap cheaper, it’s possible to make something better.

The enemies of this are the obvious — those who find copying/knockoffs/piracy easier than inventing and figuring out how to make new things and those who serve them.
And the patent trolls — those who watch for new ideas all over the world and rush to patent offices to try to claim them, then sue the people who build them later on.

Just sayin’ — flashlights are going to keep improving really, really fast — because everything is.
Seven billion people and the Internet (if not the Web, at least Usenet) to let them talk with each other without paying a toll on every word and idea that’s out there.

+1 agreed

But now what?