I’m also in the process of building a triple. I got a S2 host, but I’m not super happy with it, so I ordered a S8 which is in the mail.
I bought the carlco 10509 frosted wide optic and I like it a ton. Makes a wall of light which is perfect for my use case.
I also got the KD triple board(nichia 219c) and the optics on that are much more focused, but still very floody compared to my single emitter lights.
Also the KD board is much thinner than the noctigon 3xp and the lens’ legs protrude from the bottom. Had to snip them a little bit so the lens would put a bit of pressure on the MCPCB/spacer connection. And the carlco optics do not fit the board either, different leg sizes. Will be using the 3XP with the 10509 in my final build.
So I also picked up one of the small tubes to use an 18350 and I can’t get the light to work with the 18350, works fine with the 18650 but not the other way. Anyone have an idea on what it could be causing it? It makes no sense to me at all.
The springs are in contact with the battery?
Are you using the 18350 tube with the non anodized edge towards the tailcap and the non anodized threads towards the top?
I guess that if you are into building your S2+ collection, that could be a motivation to use the S2+ , and of course the S2+ is a very cheap host, but despite having an extensive S2+ triple line-up, ever since the Jaxman E2L host became available it has been my choice for building triples: superior performance and easier to build, and it looks better too (I love SS bezels).
Btw, if one decides on the E2L, be sure to buy the host version, the ready-made E2L’s have an almost un-removable glued ledboard.
Tube sounds like it’s a bit short, not making contact with the cap. Got some solid copper wire, you could make a ring and roll it around the inside of the cap, or solder up some multi strand and make a ring out of that and try?
light is now working, not really sure what it was. i took the tail cap apart. and the driver board out. retightened it all back down and the stupid thing works. so not sure what changed but it’s all good now. Thanks for all the help guys.