Thanks JohnnyMac! I think everyone who has some kind of measurement device should take readings, and if we all pool our results together our knowledge will grow and we can analyse all kinds of things about the lights for example, uniformity of light outputs, output, throw, etc. Because as always, more sources = more accuracy (that is if people follow the same testing method for all their lights).
Just wondering as a useful resource would it be good to have a lumen rating at 30 sec and a 2nd at 3 mins so as to show how output changes or doesn’t once the light has been on a while. A bit like the ANSI FL1 standards, but giving us a comparison.
+1
There are many variables involved here. In the first few seconds most lights sag a lot (say 10-30% -it also depends on the heatsink modding level) and so does the battery voltage of a newly charged battery (perhaps it was better to measure at 3.7V at the flat part of the discharge curve).
Even with precise measuring equipment it is unlikely that two persons will measure the same output on their respective lights of the same model.
Numbers should always be presented with details of the measuring setup and procedure.
(perhaps I’m just a grumpy old man? |( )
3mins is definitely a point where I see all flashlights truly show their constant lumens after voltage on load drops, aluminum is heated and the temperature is forcing the LED to drop the vF.
Guys, let's not over complicate this. Yes...ideally it would be nice to have a database containing every aspect of a light, including runtime charts, beam profile, heatsoak, and lumen output throughout the entire run of the battery.
Probably not going to happen... There are many different ways people use there lights. Take me, for example: Some of my most used lights are at work doing inspections...but they're quick inspections and aren't on for more than 10-15 sec, much less 3 minutes...but like I said, that's me. Also consider this: Can one really notice a slight drop in lumen value over the course of 3 to 10 minutes? For example, say Brand X light puts out 300L on start-up, but drops to 270 after a certain time period. Can one truly tell the difference after staring at the beam the entire time? I know I can't.
I'm about to post up here a lot of my own data to be added to the list. My measurements were taken just after meter stabilization, which is anywhere from 10 to 30sec.
Want to know what it is after 3min? General rule of thumb here - Subtract 10% and you'll be pretty close.
>>>>>>>>>>it’s a SkyRay A0 clone, here is the light : http://www.ebay
Thanks for the answer. I saw those two 800+ lumen fireballs and I literally couldn’t control myself and couldn’t wait, so I ordered the F15. The sky ray clone could be the next one after that though.
This lumen chart will cost me money!!!
No more guessing. I — for one — find this one of the handiest tools that BLF has to offer, even more so once it gets fleshed out.
Here’s an example of a broken rule of thumb. It is a 6W MR16 bulb being driven by a precision power supply. Driver power changed less than .005W over the 18 hour run. The light started at 420 lumens and was down to <280 lumens and still dropping (1 lux = 1 lumen on this graph). Although the temperature fairly well stabilized after 15 minutes (those pulses on the temp line are the AC cycling), the light output kept dropping.
you are completely correct, however a standardized set of conditions helps compare lights, say 10-30 secs after starting, freshly charged battery at 4.2V, model preferably listed (when possible).
For popular lights some followup would be nice, 4.0V and 3.8V, and 15 and 30mins of constant running (constant running starting from fully charged battery). I doubt many lights would get the popular light treatment, but even a half dozen best models that do would be extremely informative. I’ve been trying to put together such data from my cyclone c88, but as my PMs to you illustrate i got a dud.