I also bought a Trustfire S-A2.
I got a special 'buy 2 get 1' offer on DX, meaning that I paid for two lights and only got one.
The first light I ordered never showed up.
The only reason I continued to order from DX was that I made another order a few days after the first, which did show up.
Still trying to get my money back on that one....
Anyway, all orders I have placed with DX since that time have arrived ok, including the second Trustfire S-A2.
Thanks for confirming that it was indeed advertised as having an XP-G R5 emitter.
DX changed the description hours after I ordered it, and I thought maybe I had simply misread it!
I actually don't dislike this light as much as you do, but that's only because I made some modifications to it:
Sputtered the reflector to get rid of the horrible ringy artifacts
Made a spacer to put in front of the rubber boot in order to recess it enough for the light to tailstand
Replaced the hideous orange tailcap with a black one
So now, apart from the fact that the crenelations make the beam square, I actually like it quite a lot!
Quality seems fine, everything seems well machined and it has a real aluminum reflector and glass lens. I think I'm going to upgrade the emitter to an XM-L and see what that's like.
I like to treat these cheap lights as a 'kit' rather than a ready-to-use product, and that helps avoid a lot of disappointment :D