Since Skilhunt didn’t ask me to return my review sample, I took it apart. The large trace the RPP pin is soldered is visibly connected directly to the ground ring, making the cause of the short circuit clear. I removed the RPP pin and now have a usable light, but I would advise anyone else with a recalled light to return it rather than trying to fix it.
OMFG who would connect the reverse protection tab to ground? This is such a big screw up on the design. It’s more like Insert flat top to self destruct pin.
I wondering how it will be fixed. I don’t think if this design can work with flat tops. Positive or negative same flat surface . And all this mess for ability to use “2in1” chemistry , antique low energy density NiMH ;))
They have issued a recall and are replacing the lights, free of charge with no baloney.
Thanks to zak.wilson for catching the issue right away.
fwiw, the batteries Skillhunt recommends are protected button tops. These are safe, even with the faulty RPP post.
The grounded post issue only affects people who use
Unprotected Flat Tops. It is definitely serious.
and people who use
Unprotected button tops, only if they are inserted backwards.
In both cases, the issue is being fixed.
it is always a good idea to use the battery the manufacturer recommends… Using other batteries can sometimes cause problems. If people choose to use a non recommeded battery, it is prudent to make sure they fit the light correctly.
Thanks to zak.wilson for discovering the issue, and the prompt warning to the community. And thanks to skillhunt for the prompt recall.
It is always prudent Not to be an Early Adopter… try to be patient, and wait for feedback from reviewers such as zak.wilson, who go the extra mile to test and report.
so i have recently got the h150 v2. the “safety pin” is disconnected from the ground plane, and the board says “v2”. is it still unsafe to use flattop 14500?
then now you know your flat top works fine and you can use it if you want to
there is nothing to worry about since your light is a V2, the pin is not grounded
it does not matter that the manual does not specifically say you can use flat tops, the manual also does not say you can Not use flat tops…
on some flat tops the positive contact is slightly higher than the edge of the battery can, so they do make contact with the positive contact of the light, and they work fine.
you do do not need to worry, because your light is a V2…