@weklund: I want to know more about your impressions of that MrLifeHack popper. How much it holds relative to a standard size microwave bag, how well it works, etc. I tried reading the reviews on Amazon, and they seem to be pretty bipolar, ranging from “Most awesome thing ever OMG!
!1” to reports of “microwaved for 30 minutes and didn’t pop a single kernel” varieties. My mom had the original hard-lidded version of this:

…and it saw extensive use and got decent results.
As a kid, we ate huge amounts of stove-top popped popcorn. My first exposure to microwave popcorn was the original mid-’80s Act II at my grandparent’s house. At that time, it was different, but I really liked it.
My mother had (still has) a hot-air popper:
(I think this model)

…but I never liked the popcorn popped with that, as it was always dry and tasteless. She mostly used it when making popcorn for caramel corn or popcorn balls.
I used to eat the Pop-Weaver brand light-butter variety extensively, due to the low price compared to other brands. The light-butter had butter flavoring, but did not leave the greasy slick in my mouth like many other brands do. I had tried some of Pop-Weaver’s other varieties, but they all left me feeling like I had Crisco on the roof of my mouth afterward… :confounded:
I wanted something with a bit of a stronger flavor than the light butter, so a few years ago, I embarked on a quest to find a better microwave popcorn. I purchased packages of several brands of the microwave popcorns available in the area, including Orville Redenbacher, ActII, Jiffy-Pop, and other generic and commercial brands.
I first bought a large box of regular butter Orville Redenbacher brand, but I found it to have a weird mild-but-annoying sour aftertaste. I read the ingredients and found that it included citric acid; I found the flavor to be unpleasant so I gave most of that away. After that experiment, I began purchasing smaller packages, until I found a variety I liked.
My favorite of the Orville Redenbacher varieties is the “Tender White” in the pop-up bowl. I like that they have actually taken the time to innovate something as blasé as the old-fashioned microwave popcorn bag. The “Tender White” variety is pretty good, but not my favorite.

I eventually discovered the Pop-Secret Homestyle. I really liked this variety as it had a good saltiness, and decent flavor, but without the excessive greasy-mouthfeel aftertaste. The Homestyle has a coarser salt than your typical microwave popcorn, as if it is salted with normal table salt.
I wanted something with a stronger butter-type flavor than the Homestyle, so based on my enjoyment of the Pop-Secret brand, I purchased a small package of the “Extra-Butter” variety. My previous experiences with “Extra” and “Movie-Theater” style butter variants left me skeptical, but I found that the Pop-Secret variety was excellent. It is my current favorite due to it’s good flavor, without the grease of other brands:

I would normally be opposed to the “Pop-Secret” brand, as it violates my budget-friendly lifestyle
by tending to be the most expensive brand available. However, I have found it to be consistently excellent, with great flavor, large popped kernels, and few unpopped left behind.