Review: Lumintop SD10 (2nd generation) XM-L2 NW 1xD/3xAA/1x32650/1x26650/1x18650

41 replies [Last post]
sb56637
sb56637's picture
Offline
Last seen: 21 hours 19 min ago
Title: ==Administrator==
Joined: 01/08/2010
Posts: 4491
Location: The Light

Lumintop SD10 (2nd generation, NW emitter)

Reviewer's Overall Rating:  ★★★

 

Summary:

Battery: 1xD / 3xAA / 1x32650 / 1x26650 / 1x18650
Switch:  Electronic Side Clicky
Modes:  Low - Med - High - (Hidden Strobe)
LED Type:  XM-L2, neutral white 3C bin
Lens:  "Coated tempered glass"
Tailstands:  Yes
Retail Price:  $52.99
From:  Review Sample
Date Received:  19-OCT-2013

 

Pros:

  • Incredibly versatile battery compatibility
  • Superb runtime
  • Generally excellent design and build quality
  • Beautiful neutral white tint now available
  • Smooth beam profile with new orange peel reflector
  • Tailstands perfectly
  • Mode memory
  • Cool illuminated switch with much improved tactile feel

Cons:

  • Somewhat expensive
  • No reverse polarity protection and no orientation marking
  • Briefly holding switch to turn on/off feels unnatural
  • Hidden strobe mode can still be activated by accident

 

Introduction:

I have long preferred AA compatible flashlights due to the availability of AA cells almost everywhere. However, the D cell is quite possibly the most ubiquitous battery format around the world, being even more commonly available than AA batteries. I have personally seen zinc-carbon D cells being used in the remotest parts of the jungle, and they are commonly sold even in the smallest and poorest villages imaginable. As a flashlight enthusiast, I of course have a nice stock of alkaline, NiMH, and Li-Ion batteries charged and ready to go at all times. However, something about the possibility of buying replacement cells absolutely anywhere in case of an emergency really appeals to me. However, the selection of D cell compatible flashlights unfortunately doesn't really appeal to me. I find D Maglites to be too big and bulky to carry around, and single D cell flashlights have been virtually nonexistent up until now. Enter the Lumintop SD10. The minute I saw it in a post here on BLF I was immediately interested, and Lumintop was kind enough to provide me with two review samples. I also bought another one from HKequipment.net. Why three in total? Keep reading to find out...

 

Features / Value:  ★★★ ☆☆

The version that I am reviewing here is a new second generation model. The first generation SD10 was already reviewed here on BLF. I also received a review sample of the first generation model, and bought another one from HKequipment.net. But I didn't love the standard fare cool color of the beam. Lumintop was surprisingly responsive to my suggestion of a neutral white version, and I now have one in my hands. It is possibly the same as this one sold at HKequipment.net, but the picture there doesn't show the new orange peel reflector that mine has.

Incidentally, the new orange peel reflector is another great feature that solves my original complaint of the ugly white wall beam profile of the original version. Apart from these features, the SD10 has a really cool electronic side clicky switch, which emits a pleasant green light while pressed.

So, a modern XM-L2 neutral white emitter with a good reflector and a fancy button are all nice features. But as mentioned above, the most important feature of the SD10 is its amazing battery compatibility. It is quite simply compatible with almost anything. I have personally tested it with a zinc-carbon D cell, an alkaline D cell, 3 AA Eneloops using the included 3xAA carrier, 3x cheap chinese AA NiMHs with two of the three cells completely dead, 3 AA alkalines, a flat top Panasonic 18650, a button top Panasonic 18650, and a Trustfire 26650 cell. I don't own any 32650 cells, but it's also compatible with those. There's really nothing else like this out on the market today, and I really like it. Unfortunately, these great features do come at a bit of a premium; the Lumintop SD10 retails between $43.00 - $53.00 depending on the retailer and whether it's a first or second generation model. This is not exorbitant by any means, and as far as I know Lumintop does not have any stupid MAP schemes to artificially maintain high prices. But it's still rather more than I would like to spend. So I'm giving the SD10 three out of five stars for it's blend of nice features with a slightly elevated price.

 

Design / Build Quality:  ★★★★

The Lumintop SD10 is an extremely attractive light. I would dare to say that it's possibly one of the nicest looking lights in my collection, even when compared to other attractive options of the same size, such as the Nitecore EA4 or the Sunwayman D40A. The SD10 has no useless visual flourishes, no gaudiness, no garish fluff. It gets points for using very attractive and nice-to-the-touch matching cross-hatching on both the body and the tailcap, which is often neglected on other flashlights. Closer to the head, there is an approximately 3cm wide section of mildly ribbed heat sinking. It isn't visible in my pictures, but the white rubber side switch boot has a nice molded power symbol, which is a nice flourish. Additionally, the feel of the switch is much improved on the second generation model. The original switch was mushy and imprecise. Now, the second generation sports a visually identical switch boot, but with a nice positive "click" sound when pressed and much less concavity. The entire package is incredibly lightweight (115g), but exudes a feel of quality. The tailcap threads are smooth and well lubricated. There appear to be O-rings in all the correct places. The light tailstands very stably, and it includes a nice lanyard and an extra O-ring. All three of my samples arrived clean and free of scratches in a nice padded, compact box:

So, why not give it five stars for design and build quality? Well, I'm embarrassed to admit that I can personally attest to the fact that the SD10 does not have reverse battery polarity protection. When I received the original first generation sample from Lumintop, (which they sent by DHL (!!!) all the way from China) I promptly inserted a flat top Trustfire 26650 cell backwards and fried the circuit. To be precise, I fried just one of the three circuits that Lumintop tells me this flashlight has inside. Unfortunately, it was the one for 1xD compatibility, which most interested me about this light. The Li-Ion and 3xAA circuits continued to work, but there were occasional problems with the light continuing to glow dimly when turned off and abnormally high power consumption when turned on. So, I decided to pay for my mistake and ordered another first generation SD10 from HKequipment.net. Shortly after it arrived, Lumintop informed me that they wanted me to test the second generation neutral white edition, which I gladly accepted. So now I have a damaged but still functional first generation SD10, a good first generation SD10, and a good second generation SD10. In lieu of reverse polarity protection, I would like to see at least a polarity label inside the battery tube. The 3xAA carrier does have a "back<->front" label, but the battery tube itself does not. Apart from this major omission, there are three other minor niggles. There is only one slot on the tailcap for threading the lanyard, which means that the light tailstands on top of the lanyard tie. It's still very stable as the lanyard tie is very thin, but two holes side-by-side would have been better. Additionally, I don't like to hold the switch to turn the light on and off. And while it's nice to see that the light has a hidden strobe mode, accessible by double-clicking the switch, I find that I sometimes activate it by accident when cycling through the modes. So in summary, this is a very well constructed light that lacks reverse polarity protection. Four out of five stars for this category.

 

Battery Life:  ★★★★★

I would give the SD10 6 out of 5 stars if I could. Battery life is absolutely phenomenal on a single D cell. I have been putting off writing this review, because the regular Energizer alkaline D cell I put in the first generation SD10 almost 6 weeks ago simply will not die. It looks like Lumintop's battery runtime claims are actually correct:

The most incredible thing about the runtime is that the lowest mode is not strictly a moonlight mode. I would say that the manufacturer's 2 lumen claim is approximately correct for the low mode, which is more than adequate for many night tasks. So I am absolutely floored by its ability to produce a substantial amount of light for months on end using a single battery. All this time, I haven't noticed any change in output, which is very impressive performance on an alkaline cell. The light is significantly brighter (10 lumens) using the 3xAA carrier, but even so the runtime is still quite good at 150 hours. It's also interesting to see that it can produce 200 lumens for more than 7 hours using a D cell, or 500 lumens for 6 hours using 3 AA cells. Any way you look at it, the Lumintop is a runtime champ, and would be my first choice for being trapped in a mine shaft. I'm highly impressed.

 

Light Output:  ★★★★

The color and beam profile are drastically improved for the second generation neutral white version of the SD10. The standard cool white version uses a standard XM-L2 emitter that produces a dreary color with touches of green on one of my samples and touches of purple on the other. On the other hand, the neutral white version produces a beautiful warm, creamy light that renders colors very naturally at night. The light color appears to be the same as its neutral white peers, the Nitecore EA4W and Sunwayman D40A in neutral white. I would highly recommend the SD10 in neutral white over the depressing and sickly light of the standard cool version. Additionally, huge improvements are perceivable in the beam profile of the second generation SD10 with its light orange peel reflector.

It should be noted that the first generation SD10 (left) is running on low with an Energizer alkaline D cell, whereas the second generation SD10 (right) is on low with 3xAA Eneloops. Also, the right beam seems to have a distorted oval shape in this picture that doesn't exist in real life. But the differences in beam quality and color are quite obvious. The first generation model has a noticeably ugly ring, with murky color and shadows in the center. On the other hand, the second generation neutral white SD10 has a smooth, buttery profile, albeit slightly less focused due to the textured reflector. As for maximum brightness on high, it's quite good, but slightly less than the competition. On a single D cell, it in fact has no competition, and I would say that the manufacturer's 200 lumen claim sounds pretty accurate. On 3xAA Eneloops, the output is noticeably brighter, and further improvement is observable with three 1.5V alkaline cells. However, it can't quite match the astonishing output of the EA4 or the D40A, which run on 4xAA cells. To my eye it appears that the SD10 with a Li-Ion 18650 or 26650 cell is almost as bright as the aforementioned competition, which corresponds with Lumintop's maximum 800 lumen claim. So for almost all intents and purposes, the maximum output of the SD10 with any sort of battery configuration is more than enough. But the EA4W and the D40A still set the standard for brightness with multiple AA cells. I'll give the SD10 NW a very respectable four out of five star rating for this criteria.

 

Summary:  ★★★★

Overall, I would qualify the second generation neutral white Lumintop SD10 as a must-have light. It combines wonderful versatility with excellent build quality and good brightness and astonishing efficiency. The overall average comes to four out of five stars. Many thanks to Lumintop for producing and letting me review this excellent product.

__________________

Budget Light Forum ...where Frugal meets with Flashlight!

jdunlap27284
Offline
Last seen: 4 hours 4 min ago
Title: ★★
Joined: 02/21/2012
Posts: 181
Location: Kernersville, NC
All these reviews really make

All these reviews really make me want one!

sb56637
sb56637's picture
Offline
Last seen: 21 hours 19 min ago
Title: ==Administrator==
Joined: 01/08/2010
Posts: 4491
Location: The Light
jdunlap27284 wrote:All these

jdunlap27284 wrote:
All these reviews really make me want one!

Do it! I’m waiting for confirmation from Lumintop to see if the NW version on HKequipment is the new 2nd gen edition. They ship fast and are reputable.

__________________

Budget Light Forum ...where Frugal meets with Flashlight!

MRsDNF
MRsDNF's picture
Offline
Last seen: 36 min 31 sec ago
Title: ★★★★★
Joined: 12/22/2011
Posts: 5686
Location: A light beam away from the missus in the land of Aus.
Orsm review on a one of a

Orsm review on a one of a kind light. Thanks sb.

__________________

My current and or voltage measurements are only relevent to anything that I measure. Budget light hobby proudly sponsored by my Mastercard and unkowingly paid for by a hard working wife. Free plug for my daughter. http://missymupsnails.com.au/

zelee
zelee's picture
Online
Last seen: 2 min 54 sec ago
Title: ★★★★
Joined: 06/04/2013
Posts: 925
must resist…..

must resist….. Puzzled

Chicken Drumstick
Offline
Last seen: 4 hours 59 min ago
Title: ★★★★★
Joined: 08/27/2012
Posts: 1141
Location: UK
Great review. Many thanks.

Great review. Many thanks. Feel a bit time warpy though with the review date of the 26th Oct 2013 Wink

__________________

My torch & flashlight reviews: http://budgetlightforum.com/node/10711?page=1#comment-220843

jacktheclipper
jacktheclipper's picture
Offline
Last seen: 2 hours 37 min ago
Title: ★★★★★
Joined: 10/31/2010
Posts: 3850
Location: Florida , U.S.A.
...

Thanks for the review .

Cool

__________________

My Paracord Stuff

moderator007
moderator007's picture
Offline
Last seen: 31 weeks 4 days ago
Title: ★★★★★
Joined: 12/23/2012
Posts: 1411
Location: North Carolina
Well, if I was a moderator

Well, if I was a moderator here I would just have to give you one of those
“Front Paged and Sticky’d” post. Big smile
Great job SB.

JohnnyMac
JohnnyMac's picture
Offline
Last seen: 19 min 26 sec ago
Title: ★★★★★
Joined: 04/12/2011
Posts: 8094
Location: Eastern PA
Good review, SB! I really

Good review, SB! I really like this light and it's only a matter of time before I have one in my grubby mitts. Smile

__________________

The Flashlight Forum (TFF)
The Vaping Forum (TVF)
My OTF Lumen and Lux datasheet

Visit my review blog:  JOHNNY MAC REVIEWS 

sb56637
sb56637's picture
Offline
Last seen: 21 hours 19 min ago
Title: ==Administrator==
Joined: 01/08/2010
Posts: 4491
Location: The Light
Chicken Drumstick wrote:Great

Chicken Drumstick wrote:
Great review. Many thanks. Feel a bit time warpy though with the review date of the 26th Oct 2013 ;)

Oops! Thanks for letting me know.

__________________

Budget Light Forum ...where Frugal meets with Flashlight!

brad
brad's picture
Offline
Last seen: 1 hour 39 min ago
Title: ★★★★★
Joined: 12/04/2012
Posts: 951
Location: USA
Is this light designed to

Is this light designed to reduce the chance of being ruined by leaking batteries?

That seems like it would be an important part of a survival light designed to run off of whatever people can find in their drawers and closets.

__________________

panthervision23
Offline
Last seen: 40 weeks 1 day ago
Title: ★★★
Joined: 02/19/2013
Posts: 547
Nice! Another

Nice! Another collector-worthy item.

S)
sb56637
sb56637's picture
Offline
Last seen: 21 hours 19 min ago
Title: ==Administrator==
Joined: 01/08/2010
Posts: 4491
Location: The Light
brad wrote:Is this light

brad wrote:
Is this light designed to reduce the chance of being ruined by leaking batteries?

That seems like it would be an important part of a survival light designed to run off of whatever people can find in their drawers and closets.

Good question. In fact I have been worried that this Alkaleak I have in it right now will start to do its thing after a 6 weeks of non stop use…

__________________

Budget Light Forum ...where Frugal meets with Flashlight!

JohnnyMac
JohnnyMac's picture
Offline
Last seen: 19 min 26 sec ago
Title: ★★★★★
Joined: 04/12/2011
Posts: 8094
Location: Eastern PA
Hey, SB, have you noticed any

Hey, SB, have you noticed any parasitic loss with the electronic switch?  Is it able to be locked out? 

__________________

The Flashlight Forum (TFF)
The Vaping Forum (TVF)
My OTF Lumen and Lux datasheet

Visit my review blog:  JOHNNY MAC REVIEWS 

sb56637
sb56637's picture
Offline
Last seen: 21 hours 19 min ago
Title: ==Administrator==
Joined: 01/08/2010
Posts: 4491
Location: The Light
JohnnyMac wrote:Hey, SB, have

JohnnyMac wrote:

Hey, SB, have you noticed any parasitic loss with the electronic switch?  Is it able to be locked out? 

I was wondering about that too. I’m not exactly sure how to test it. I figured that if the light can be turned ON for 60 days nonstop, then it should be able to sit for a long time turned OFF as well. There is no electronic interface lockout mode, but the circuit can be opened with a turn of about 20 degrees of the tailcap.

__________________

Budget Light Forum ...where Frugal meets with Flashlight!

RaceR86
RaceR86's picture
Online
Last seen: 4 min 7 sec ago
Title: ★★★★★
Joined: 02/22/2012
Posts: 3598
Location: Norway
Very nice review SB!Thanks!

Very nice review SB!

Thanks!

__________________

BLF LED database - collaboration spreadsheet and latest news about where to buy LEDs http://budgetlightforum.com/node/19342

sb56637
sb56637's picture
Offline
Last seen: 21 hours 19 min ago
Title: ==Administrator==
Joined: 01/08/2010
Posts: 4491
Location: The Light
I also wanted to ask you guys

I also wanted to ask you guys about the horizontal banding that appeared in my beamshot picture. Would that be a sign of PWM? I tried to look for PWM, but I still can’t tell if it has it or not. Through my smartphone’s screen I don’t see any pulsation or banding of the SD10’s light. I’m fairly sensitive to the lower frequency PWM found in some lights, so if the SD10 has PWM it must be a pretty high frequency. I’ve had the beam in my peripheral vision near my computer for over a month now, and I haven’t detected anything yet.

__________________

Budget Light Forum ...where Frugal meets with Flashlight!

JohnnyMac
JohnnyMac's picture
Offline
Last seen: 19 min 26 sec ago
Title: ★★★★★
Joined: 04/12/2011
Posts: 8094
Location: Eastern PA
sb56637 wrote:I also wanted

sb56637 wrote:
I also wanted to ask you guys about the horizontal banding that appeared in my beamshot picture. Would that be a sign of PWM? I tried to look for PWM, but I still can't tell if it has it or not. Through my smartphone's screen I don't see any pulsation or banding of the SD10's light. I'm fairly sensitive to the lower frequency PWM found in some lights, so if the SD10 has PWM it must be a pretty high frequency. I've had the beam in my peripheral vision near my computer for over a month now, and I haven't detected anything yet.
That would be caused by PWM.  The easiest way to see PWM is to point the light at a running ceiling fan or even the fan at the back of your PC.  If the fan appears as a smooth blur then there is no PWM.  If it looks like lots of blades spinning then you have PWM.  If you play with different lights you will soon get a feel for the speed of the PWM.  Slower PWM makes the blades seem farther apart from each other but a fast PWM will make it almost look like the blades are close enough together that they overlap.

Another real easy way is to run water in the sink or shower at night with the lights off.  Shine your light at it and if it looks like you can see individual droplets then you are seeing PWM in effect.  It's easy to see the PWM this way but is difficult to judge the speed of the PWM compared to the fan method.

Lights with PWM bother me when walking the dog at night.  If I run the beam across the ground along side of me and follow the hotspot with my eyes unfocused the grass appears to be "digital".  Once you try it you will see exactly what I mean by that.  With a light with no PWM the grass is a smooth blur.  The slower the PWM the more dramatic the effect. Wink

__________________

The Flashlight Forum (TFF)
The Vaping Forum (TVF)
My OTF Lumen and Lux datasheet

Visit my review blog:  JOHNNY MAC REVIEWS 

sb56637
sb56637's picture
Offline
Last seen: 21 hours 19 min ago
Title: ==Administrator==
Joined: 01/08/2010
Posts: 4491
Location: The Light
Thanks Johnny! Ah yes, I

Thanks Johnny! Ah yes, I forgot about the running water trick. I’ll give it a quick test tonight.

__________________

Budget Light Forum ...where Frugal meets with Flashlight!

moderator007
moderator007's picture
Offline
Last seen: 31 weeks 4 days ago
Title: ★★★★★
Joined: 12/23/2012
Posts: 1411
Location: North Carolina
Parasitic drain, set the DMM

Parasitic drain, set the DMM to read milliamps. Measure the same way as taking a current tail cap reading, except this time with the light off. Any current flowing through the meter with the light off, would indicate some parasitic drain.

vēer
vēer's picture
Offline
Last seen: 3 days 8 hours ago
Title: ★★★★★
Joined: 01/07/2012
Posts: 1780
Location: Europe
Great review, sb, I wish more

Great review, sb, I wish more manufacturers would make multi-chemistry+battery size lights, at the moment SD10 is the only model to get if you like your lithiums just like your NiMh’s, fully charged and blasting on high Laughing out loud!

My review here , I have to agree, this is great light and given that so far it has gathered 3 4 reviews and everyone seems to like it there is no reason not to get one Laughing out loud!

Racer
Racer's picture
Online
Last seen: 5 min 1 sec ago
Title: ★★★★★
Joined: 05/06/2013
Posts: 1289
Location: Spokane, WA
The lights I have with really

The lights I have with really high frequency PWM do not show their PWM on the fan or running water tests. The only way I can see the PWM on lights such as my Roche F12 is by using the cell phone camera, and even then it’s hard to see it. I have to hold the light and camera really still. The higher frequency the PWM, the finer the interference pattern on the phone.

It helps to point the camera straight at the LED, like this picture below. I had to play around with the angles before it gave me a good view of it like this. Pointing it anything other than dead on it’s really hard to see.

brad
brad's picture
Offline
Last seen: 1 hour 39 min ago
Title: ★★★★★
Joined: 12/04/2012
Posts: 951
Location: USA
vēer wrote:Great review, sb,

vēer wrote:
Great review, sb, I wish more manufacturers would make multi-chemistry+battery size lights, at the moment SD10 is the only model to get if you like your lithiums just like your NiMh’s, fully charged and blasting on high Laughing out loud!

My review here , I have to agree, this is great light and given that so far it has gathered 3 4 reviews and everyone seems to like it there is no reason not to get one Laughing out loud!

I still have what should be an obvious question for an emergency light meant to use any battery, will leaking alkalines ruin it?

__________________

Racer
Racer's picture
Online
Last seen: 5 min 1 sec ago
Title: ★★★★★
Joined: 05/06/2013
Posts: 1289
Location: Spokane, WA
Leaky alkalines could

Leaky alkalines could potentially ruin any device.

vēer
vēer's picture
Offline
Last seen: 3 days 8 hours ago
Title: ★★★★★
Joined: 01/07/2012
Posts: 1780
Location: Europe
Racer wrote:Leaky alkalines

Racer wrote:
Leaky alkalines could potentially ruin any device.

This.

Also, keep in mind that this light has NO reverse polarity protection, thats another thing to consider if youre concerned about battery related issues Wink!

brad
brad's picture
Offline
Last seen: 1 hour 39 min ago
Title: ★★★★★
Joined: 12/04/2012
Posts: 951
Location: USA
But realistically, can’t

But realistically, can’t there be some measure of basic protection designed in simply enough? Can’t a light be made less susceptible, if not impervious, to battery damage?

An emergency light built for all batteries and fully intended for the ones you rob from remotes and the kid’s toys, seems pretty fragile if you can ruin it the first week you buy it, just because your batteries leaked, which is very common where I live.

Don’t the simple plastic battery holders offer a large degree of protection from the batteries that fit them, even though that isn’t the intention?

__________________

gords1001
gords1001's picture
Offline
Last seen: 21 weeks 11 hours ago
Title: ★★★★★
Joined: 05/07/2012
Posts: 5192
Location: wigan england
great review sb, I actually

great review sb, I actually DO have a spare 32650 cell, bought with this light or a 1d maglite in mind, I might just have to treat myself to one of these for all of the options available though.

Thanks Stare Big smile

brad
brad's picture
Offline
Last seen: 1 hour 39 min ago
Title: ★★★★★
Joined: 12/04/2012
Posts: 951
Location: USA
vēer wrote: Also, keep in

vēer wrote:

Also, keep in mind that this light has NO reverse polarity protection, thats another thing to consider if youre concerned about battery related issues Wink!

Wow, I don’t get how these fatal flaws can be left in an emergency light.

__________________

vēer
vēer's picture
Offline
Last seen: 3 days 8 hours ago
Title: ★★★★★
Joined: 01/07/2012
Posts: 1780
Location: Europe
Lets hope that there will be

Lets hope that there will be an update soonish Wink!

captainwatty
Offline
Last seen: 28 weeks 5 days ago
Title: ★★
Joined: 10/14/2013
Posts: 18
Leaky alkalines

I have been in the habit of storing emergency lights with the batteries in them. I use scotch tape to fully cover both terminal ends, which keeps them from draining. I wonder if a similar approach would help protect against leaks. Heat shrink tubing comes to mind, but maybe something as simple as wrapping the batteries in plastic wrap would work.

I am guessing the easy solution for the reverse polarity, adding a diode in series, would rob a single D cell of too much voltage (0.6 volt drop). However, the carrier could have one built in…

Streamer
Streamer's picture
Offline
Last seen: 10 hours 50 min ago
Title: ★★★★★
Joined: 12/01/2011
Posts: 1423
Location: TX
I’‘ve eyeballed the SD10 for

I’‘ve eyeballed the SD10 for quite a while, but decided it would be foolish to purchase with no battery polarity protection built in. I mean, you’re in a storm and graspin for batteries to utilize when you realize…oh oh…..wrong way.

Even SB admitted to fryin his first one.

Come on Lumintiop…Update Update Update !

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.