I would like to see that the whole isn’t that large. 5 or 6mm for the wires is enough. The screws have to be longer and need to connect sshelf, MCPCB and Reflektor.
And why we dont get a dual footprint MCPCB, the space for costom MCPCBs needs to be larger. Now there is only space for the diameter of the stock MCPCB. We need more space to the outer of the flashlight.
Wow welcome all new members!
I will update list later and when time is due (it is done when done, communication with China is going slow and Barry does not seem to be back yet, and it must be good before it can be sold) a PM is send. But before that this thread will likely explode
Wiesel, the proto has the ledboard screwed on to the shelf.
And the reflector has a “hollow center” underside to accommodate wires.
So screwing the reflector to the ledboard and shelf does not seem ideal.
Tom also noted the hole could be smaller now but I think Thorfire now can use a very thick walled tube instead of a solid bar to make the head.
Also adapting the shelf by removing the edge around the ledboard and making the hold smaller would mean more mass right below the ledboard and a smaller heatpath to the rest of the housing.
Yes it does not harm to ask for that ledboard with two sets of pads for LEDs so XML foot printed LEDs can be used on it
This would not add costs so will do that!
Two sets of LED-Pads would be very nice and enough for the most modders. And it would be enough for my first plans with XHP50.2.
But this flashlight was aimed as modding-base. And therefore I would nicely see a larger mcpcb respectively enough space to fit 4x 16mm MCPCBs. … for those who want to use it with XHP70 or Nichia 144 or so on.
That means at least 38,7mm if the center of the 16mm MCPCBs fits the Reflector holes. (Here is a helping calculation to fit circles in a bigger circle: Circle Packing -- from Wolfram MathWorld)
Well, as far as giving away lights for “advertising” purposes, I’d say limit it to one per person here, which would cut down the total quantity quite a bit. Maybe even limit it to a few hundred free lights. The remainder of the list ( second, third, fourth, etc. lights) could pay the $40 price. I do believe that if Thorfire really played this right, made a high quality light, and pushed it out there, they could sell it later (after this GB ends) for over $100 easily. That would be a reasonable price for this light, as it is designed now. They’d certainly make up their “advertising” cost from the future sales.
This is a great opportunity for Thorfire, whether they realize it or not. On the flip side, if they cheap out and don’t deliver as promised, or if they screw around and try to jack up the price on us, after all the free “engineering” we’ve given them, the negative attention can cost them dearly in lost future business, not only of this light, but of their entire line.
Yes, found my notes - brought my notebook with me to work. Dimensions in my notes match post above.
The bottom line is my vote will be whatever is quickest. If they have not changed the MCPCB since the early proto (accept for accommodation of screws to secure down the reflector), then leave it as is. We need to get this done. We've been through all this before, many times, 100's of posts. For me, I believe the MCPCB is a big reason why this light gets such great performance, a performance I could not duplicate with a 4X SRK clone using 4 16 mm Noctigon's with equivalent XM-L2 U3 3D LED's, sitting on a copper plate used as a shelf. I think it has mainly to do with being able to use 18 AWG wires and it's large size of 35.8 mm diameter, while on the 4X SRK clone I could only use 4 separate pairs of 22 AWG because of clearances and having 4 pairs of pads to solder to. The ThorFire MCPCB uses a single pair of 18 AWG wires, one pair of pads, and the big wire on the pads easily fit.
We won't know what they've changed, where they are at til we get the next round of information from them. We are waiting for a response, assuming they will be back, or back soon from holiday.
35,8mm is not verry good. Due to my math on the picture, a 16mm MCPCB has to be sanded down 3,3mm at one side to fit.
I think 39mm or better 40mm would be great. Its not nessesary to change the size of the actual ThorFire MCPCB, but the space on the shelf needs to be enlarged!
As Modding Platform as aimed too, it is realy nessesary that we get the dual-footprint MCPCB like written by The Miller (and aimed/discussed in the OP) and have the ability to use 16mm MCPCBs for all other Footprints different to XP/35 and XM/50.
With dual-footprint, we could transfer the big performance of the first proto (as explained by Tom E) to other LED-options with XM-footprint, wich is a big advantage.
Edit: I did some mistake by calculating the needed space. So I edited this post.
I don't know if that design of the MCPCB was related to ThorFire, if it was, it was totally ignored for the first prototype. Don't recall if they were ever asked to correct this. As you are probably aware, the engineering team was switched out, so I'm not clear on what the new team understands of the requirements. Again, communication is greatly lacking, non-existent in the last few weeks, so we really don't know. They also had great troubles with the specs we've given them in the past, so anything that complicated has major problems, so I'm doubting they went and ahead and did it, and had no questions of us - maybe they did it, I really don't know. If not accommodated, again, my vote would be not to change - no more delays for non-essential changes at this point.
Changing to 6V or 12V LED's would not be an easy mod for the 2S or 4S cell capability as well.
Hm sure I emailed the dual footprint ledboard but I cant recall if it was the very complex one with all the extra pads for fuses and such
After reading Tons post I have to agree with him asking for such a elaborate designed ledboard is very very tricky while we now have a full copper DTP ledboard that seemed like a far fetched dream at the beginning of the project. Maybe just be very happy with that right?
With the flashlight as it is, I am happy. But as modding-platform I am unhappy with it.
If you dont want to change the MCPCB to dual footprint, than please give modders enough space to use custom 16mm MCPCBs. That means enlarge the space for MCPCBs to 40mm and I will be happy.
I see in the referenced drawing above and in the OP, it does look like the MCPCB was spec'd out that short, not the full width, though there's no physical dimensions listed in the OP. There seems to be some material, shaded darker gray, that prevents it from going the full width. I don't know what that dark gray material is supposed to be, but it continues up the interior wall. In the prototype from my pics, that space from the MCPCB to the outer edge is simply a raised portion of the shelf, extending to the exterior wall.
I don't know what happened here, but it appears to me they simply built the MCPCB to the dimensions we provided from that drawing?
I’m really not sure what the fuss is about a modders light. This light is tuned and tweaked by modders, for those that CAN’T mod, so it comes as a fully modified master blaster right out of the box, just as if Tom or myself or any number of other modders here had taken liberty with an SRK. So, with so much time already invested and with so many people already on board according to the design, it’s too late for changes.
The oversized center hole in the emitter shelf directs heat outward toward the cooling fins. Should work brilliantly. The size and style of the mcpcb is perfect. If one want’s to Mod the light, then they need to do some work, if it’s too easy, it isn’t modding!
I vote for Green light, pending prototype results. Edit: To be clear, I’m saying Green Light the project, give it a Go, Pass it and put it in production. Prototype results pending, of course.